Sora's Dead, Seedance Is Broken, and Disney's on ‘Read’.
... still wondering if robots have celluloid dreams.
Machine Cinema is home to the creators, builders, and business insiders defining the future of media and entertainment. The conversation that matters is happening here.
Too busy to read? Listen to the pod instead.
Sunday Edition — Double Issue
Edited by Elizabeth Kealoha. Pod + Images by Ant Neely.
In AI, a week is a lifetime. Here’s what happened over the last two!
OpenAI killed Sora, Disney scrambled, Seedance dropped (then degraded), and the community spent two straight weeks debating what actually matters in a world where anyone can make anything. Meanwhile, a Machine Cinema member is executive producing an A24 film, two members got Webby nominations, and Minh thinks this will be the biggest year in cinema history. Agree or disagree, the conversations were worth having.
Let’s get into it — double edition.
TWO WEEKS IN ‘COMMUNITY’
Sora Is Gone — And Nobody Agrees on Why
The biggest story of the fortnight dropped on March 24: OpenAI is shutting down the Sora consumer app. The community reacted instantly — and kept reacting for days. Mike OverJK, who had just finished a 20-minute film praising Sora, joked that his love letter would become a eulogy. Danny R. suggested he re-title it “Sora — A Retrospective.” The strategic debate ran deeper: Minh argued the shutdown wasn’t about failure but about OpenAI refocusing on enterprise and their upcoming IPO. Fred pushed back — “I’m pretty sure you keep things going when they’re working and shut them down when they’re not.” Francesco wasn’t surprised either, noting Chinese models had surpassed Sora and questioning why OpenAI targeted mass consumers instead of professionals. The Disney angle added another layer, with Jay J. flagging the now-awkward Sora/Disney partnership and Kenny predicting Disney would “turn around and do a deal with Bytedance on Seedream.”
[BASECAMP]
Seedance 2.0: The Alpha Was Better
When Seedance 2.0 finally launched publicly, the reactions were mixed — and Hussein didn’t hold back. “Prompt adherence dropped, camera control is weaker, motion feels less natural,” he wrote, calling out a growing problem: “We commit to clients based on capabilities that later disappear or degrade. That puts all the risk on us while the platforms keep shifting.” It hit a nerve for anyone building a business on these tools.
[BASECAMP]
Trust Is the New Metric — Not Content, Not Attention
A sprawling, multi-day philosophical thread kicked off when one member argued that product quality still matters most. Minh disagreed: “Marketing and distribution matter more than product because it has become so easy to build and clone any product.” MG stepped in with a framework he calls the Human Connection Economy — a four-layer model (Attention → Creation → Experience → Trust) arguing that brands need to stop chasing eyeballs and start forging long-tail relationships. “In an age of diminishing content costs and the flood of impressions we receive daily, content is no longer king,” MG wrote. “Trust is the new metric.” The thread touched on Nvidia’s latest announcement, the defensibility of curation, and why human trust may be the last real moat.
[BASECAMP]
Hannah Einbinder, Del Toro, and the Privilege to Dunk on AI
When Vulture ran a piece featuring Hacks actress Hannah Einbinder criticizing AI, the community lit up. Minh's response was sharp: "Never heard of you until you shat on AI. Congrats on using AI to get famous." Jay offered a more nuanced take — he likes Einbinder and her work, but called the stance "shitty." The conversation evolved into something bigger when Minh pointed out that Del Toro's family won the lottery, enabling his film career. "I think with privilege comes the space to dunk on AI," Minh wrote. Sarah agreed: "For those without access to high budgets, AI is opening the doors to indie filmmakers." MG closed the thread with conviction: "Don't listen to the noise. Keep looking up. The only ones you are accountable to is yourself and your creative vision."
[BASECAMP]
Handmade vs. Machine-Made: The Luxury Bifurcation
A quieter but potent thread emerged around whether cinema is splitting into two tiers. Jennifer laid it out: "Maybe 95% of film, TV, ads, games are 'off the rack'… AI dominates in that market. And then 'handmade' film/TV offerings become the couture market." MG agreed — "totally polarized ends of spectrums, both with different models, hollowing out the middle." Matt brought in Brian Eno's philosophy: "It's the imperfections that we crave… which is why we go back to retro so much." The conversation also touched on new SAG-AFTRA strike threats, with Jennifer asking a question that lingered: if AI-friendly non-union work keeps growing, "how beneficial is SAG membership to 95% of the current members if it prevents them from taking non-union jobs?"
[BASECAMP]
🏆 COMMUNITY WINS
Big moves from the MC family over the past two weeks:
Chris White — Executive Producer on Backrooms, produced with Atomic Monster, A24, Chernin Entertainment, and 21 Laps. In theaters May 29th.
Kimberly Offord — Nominated for a Webby Award in AI Creativity & Storytelling.
Aaron Bhugobaun — Nominated for a Webby Award for Best Thought Leadership. Also launching an Industry Creative Working Group to push AI conversations forward.
Diane Laidlaw — Hosting TED AI’s first AI Filmmaking Competition in Vienna this October. 90-second horror shorts, screening in a 100-year-old cinema.
Junie — Released AURAE, an AI short film exploring the absence of female heroes in Asian mythology. Fred called her a “living legend.”
Leonid Krykhtin — Collaborating on OMNI Shanghai: “AI EMOTION — 感動,” a regional AI film festival edition (March 28–30).
Danny Ratcliff — Released an AI spec ad for Land Rover Defender, continuing his “AI is punk” creative thesis.
GenTalks:
MythOS: Building Collaborative AI Story Worlds (Week One)
🎬 RSVP / Watch →
The community buzzed about the MythOS project getting the Gen Talks spotlight, with Joanna noting “lots of Basecampers on the project!” Sasha called the session “gonna be 🔥” ahead of the March 25 call. MythOS represents a growing interest in collaborative, lore-adherent AI storytelling.
Unlocking AI-Driven Content Creation and Distribution (Week Two)
🎬 RSVP / Watch →
Tiffany Lee Joseph (Award-winning AI filmmaker and creative technologist who presented at Nvidia GTC, building AI-native production systems for networks and agencies) + Daniel Roberts (CEO and co-founder of Alchemy streaming platform on Roku and Apple TV, former entrepreneur-in-residence at Sandbox Industries).
Machine Cinema Events This Week…
SFSF Salon: Session 02
📅 Wednesday, April 8 · 7:00 PM CDT
RSVP
GenTalks with Ari Kuschnir & Matt Zien
📅 Wednesday, April 8 · 1:00 PM EDT
RSVP
🔗 This Week’s Link Drops
Industry News
OpenAI discontinues Sora video platform — The Guardian
OpenAI acquires TBPN — OpenAI
UK government changes position on AI copyright — Screen Daily
White House AI rollout rift — Axios
AI Filmmaking & Creative
Gossip Goblin / Zack London AI films in Hollywood Reporter — THR
AI-generated singer “Eddie Dalton” hits #1 on iTunes — Showbiz411
Chinese AI Cinema analysis by Francesco D’Isa — The Bunker
Sora is dead — The Ankler’s take — The Ankler
Tools & Tech
Runway introduces multi-shot — Runway
Google Flow by Google — Google
Koyal V2.5 launched — Mehul Agarwal
Buzbee AI alpha is live — Buzbee
Suno v5.5 voice features — via Kai
Topaz Starlight Precise 2.5 — Topaz Labs
Worth Watching
Karpathy’s AI job exposure map — Andrej Karpathy
Meta brain-to-video research — Meta AI
Competitions & Opportunities
Future Vision XPRIZE — XPRIZE
Runway Big Ad Competition — Runway
WHEN ONE DOOR CLOSES…
Two weeks of noise, signal, grief, and ambition. Sora's gone, but the conversations it sparked aren't — about trust, about craft, about who gets to make things and who gets to gatekeep. The tools will keep changing. The people in this community won't stop building.
See you next Sunday.
— Machine Cinema Newsletter
We want to hear from you. Have ideas for the newsletter? Let us know.